Short answer: For small salons that handle both walk-ins and appointments, SupaDay offers the best combination of features and value at $14/user/month (capped at $99). For solo stylists who want dead-simple booking, GlossGenius is a strong choice. Fresha starts at $14.95/user/month plus 20% commission on new marketplace clients.

Choosing salon software when you have 1-5 chairs shouldn't require a demo, a sales call, and a spreadsheet to compare pricing tiers. But that's what most apps put you through.

We looked at six popular scheduling apps for small salons and compared what actually matters: pricing as your team grows, what's included vs. what costs extra, and whether the app handles both walk-ins and appointments.

The apps we compared

  1. SupaDay — salon software with walk-in turn tracking and flat per-user pricing
  2. Vagaro — popular with salons, lots of features but add-ons add up
  3. GlossGenius — clean and simple, popular with independent stylists
  4. Fresha — marketplace-driven with commission fees on new clients
  5. Square Appointments — part of the Square ecosystem
  6. Mangomint — premium, polished, higher price point

Quick comparison

Feature SupaDay Vagaro GlossGenius Fresha Square Mangomint
Online booking Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
SMS reminders Included Included Included Limited free Paid add-on Paid overages
Walk-in turn tracker Yes No No No No No
Commission tracking Grow plan Yes Gold+ only Team plan No Premium only
Website builder Business plan $20/mo extra Basic No No Basic
QR check-in Yes Add-on No No No No
Marketplace commission 0% 0% 0% 20% on new clients 0% 0%
Free trial 30 days 30 days 14 days 7 days Free tier 14 days

How each app stacks up

SupaDay — best for salons that take walk-ins

SupaDay's Grow plan ($14/user/month, capped at $99/month) includes online booking, SMS reminders, commission tracking, walk-in turn tracker, QR check-in, and POS checkout. The Business plan ($22/user/month, capped at $149/month) adds a website builder, reviews and reputation management, and higher SMS allowances.

What stands out:

  • Only app on this list with a built-in walk-in turn tracker — determines whose turn it is to take the next walk-in — fair, transparent, automatic
  • Monthly cap keeps pricing predictable — a 7-person team on Grow pays $98/month (under the $99 cap), not $98 per person
  • SMS reminders, commission tracking, and QR check-in included on the Grow plan — no add-ons

Watch out for:

  • Website builder and reviews require the Business plan
  • If you just need booking, scheduling, and walk-in management, the Grow plan covers it

Best for: Small salons that take both walk-ins and appointments and want fair turn rotation built in.

Vagaro — feature-rich but add-ons add up

Vagaro has a long feature list, but several essentials are paid extras. SMS marketing is $20+/month. The website builder is $20/month plus a $299 design fee. You're locked into Vagaro's payment processor — no Stripe option.

What stands out:

  • Large marketplace that can send you new clients
  • Comprehensive feature set if you're willing to pay for add-ons

Watch out for:

  • SMS marketing + website = $40+/month on top of base subscription
  • No walk-in turn tracker, no audit trail
  • Locked into Vagaro's payment processor — no Stripe
  • See full comparison →

Best for: Salons that want marketplace exposure and don't mind add-on pricing.

GlossGenius — simple and pretty

GlossGenius is beautifully designed and easy to set up. It's popular with solo stylists and booth renters because it just works out of the box.

What stands out:

  • Clean, mobile-first interface
  • Setup takes minutes — no training needed

Watch out for:

  • Commission tracking locked to Gold+ ($48+/month)
  • Website builder doesn't support custom domains
  • No walk-in management, no QR check-in
  • Limitations show as your team grows past 2-3 stylists
  • See full comparison →

Best for: Solo stylists or booth renters who want something simple and don't need team features.

Fresha — marketplace-driven with commission fees

Fresha charges $19.95/month for solo practitioners or $14.95/user/month for teams. On top of the subscription, they take a 20% commission (minimum $6) on new clients from their marketplace. Payment processing runs 2.29-2.79% + $0.20 per transaction.

What stands out:

  • Built-in marketplace that can bring in new clients
  • Lower per-user pricing for larger teams

Watch out for:

  • 20% marketplace commission on new clients — on top of the monthly subscription
  • SMS limited to 100 free/month, then $0.02 per text
  • No website builder
  • See full comparison →

Best for: Salons that want marketplace exposure to attract new clients and don't mind paying commission on marketplace bookings.

Square Appointments — good if you're already on Square

Square Appointments makes sense if your salon already uses Square for payments. Scheduling integrates with Square POS and their broader ecosystem (invoicing, payroll, banking).

What stands out:

  • Tight integration with Square POS and ecosystem
  • Free tier genuinely useful for solo practitioners

Watch out for:

  • SMS reminders are a paid add-on
  • No commission tracking, no walk-in management
  • It's a scheduling layer on a payments company — not purpose-built salon software
  • See full comparison →

Best for: Solo stylists already using Square POS who want basic scheduling added on.

Mangomint — premium and polished

Mangomint is the most refined salon software on this list. The UI is beautiful, the automation is powerful, and customer support is excellent.

What stands out:

  • Smart automations and gorgeous interface
  • Strong integrations and excellent customer support

Watch out for:

  • Higher starting price than most alternatives
  • Commission tracking requires Premium tier ($149+/month)
  • No walk-in turn tracker
  • See full comparison →

Best for: Established salons with budget for premium software and no walk-in traffic.

So which one should you pick?

It depends on your situation:

  • Take walk-ins and appointments?SupaDay — only one with a built-in turn tracker
  • Solo stylist, want dead-simple? → GlossGenius
  • Want a marketplace to bring in new clients? → Fresha
  • Already on Square? → Square Appointments
  • Budget for premium? → Mangomint
  • Want a marketplace? → Vagaro

For most small salons with 1-5 stylists that handle both walk-ins and booked clients, SupaDay gives you the features that matter most — turn tracking, online booking, SMS reminders, and commission tracking — at a predictable price that doesn't spike as you add staff.

Try SupaDay free for 30 days →